The biggest SEO mistake when selling on Etsy

Etsy, eBay, Amazon
July 31, 2024
7 Minutes

Content

Brief Summary

The main mistake of Etsy SEO — when a seller only describes the product features, and not what exactly the buyer is looking for and why they need this product. The article shows how to shift from a “seller’s language” to search language, usefulness, and intent to increase the number of relevant long-tail queries.

Who this article is for

  • For Etsy sellers who want to improve the visibility of their listings in search.
  • For handmade, art, printable, and print-on-demand stores.
  • For those who want to learn how to select keywords based on buyer intent rather than internal product descriptions.

Main Point

To improve Etsy SEO, you need to write titles and keywords not as a seller, but as a buyer: start from the product’s purpose, usage scenario, gift goal, style, room, recipient, or need. This way, the listing covers more long-tail queries.

Image 001

Main SEO mistake

The biggest problem I see with SEO is that sellers only use their titles to describe the product itself, not its purpose. Etsy sellers in their business are so product-focused that it’s very easy for them to fall into the trap when it comes to SEO. They are used to describing color, size, materials used, some words written on the product, etc. And this is instead of describing the purpose or usefulness of the product through SEO.

The problem is that they think more like a seller than a buyer, so they are obsessed with describing the product’s specifics rather than the solution or benefit it provides to the customer.

How to Improve Etsy SEO: Step by Step

  1. Look at the listing through the eyes of a buyer: not how you describe the product, but how it might be searched for.
  2. Remove unnecessary “internal” words: collection names, artistic titles, technical details without search value.
  3. Start the title with the strongest phrase: the first words should contain the main query.
  4. Add benefits and purpose: who the product is for, where it is used, how it is used, in what situation it is bought.
  5. Use long-tail keywords: combine product, intent, style, recipient, event.
  6. Check punctuation and structure: avoid overloading the title with dashes, colons, and random inserts.
  7. Create a second variation of the listing: use a different set of long-tail keywords for broader coverage.
  8. Update photos to match the new search intent: visuals should also align with the new positioning.

How the seller thinks and how the buyer searches

Seller’s approach Buyer’s approach What’s better for Etsy SEO
Describes the characteristics of the product Looks for a solution, style, or purpose Focus on the buyer’s search intent
Uses internal or “pretty” names Enter simple and understandable phrases Simple commercial formulations
Places unhelpful words in the title Immediately searches for the key phrase The strongest query at the beginning of the title
Creates a narrow one-word title Searches with various phrasing options Several long-tail variations

How do buyers search on Etsy

Buyers are searching quite differently from us, Etsy sellers. When people come to Etsy, they are looking for a solution, meaning they are not searching for specific parameters of a particular product. This is one of the main differences between Etsy and eBay. When a buyer comes to Etsy, you know they are looking for a Father’s Day gift, not a 10-millimeter nut with epoxy coating XYZ.

Key Etsy SEO Rules from this article

  • Don’t just describe the product — describe its benefits and use case.
  • Don’t think like a seller — think like a buyer searching on Etsy.
  • The first words of the title — the most valuable for SEO.
  • Long-tail keywords provide broader search coverage.
  • One idea — multiple positioning variations through new titles and new photos.

Bonus: Tips from Etsy sales professionals

If you’ve read this far, I want to give you a bonus tip that you should implement in all your ads right now.

‍When buyers search for a product, they often start by entering a noun, then adjectives describing that noun. But I see many sellers placing these specific adjectives and descriptors directly before the noun in their headlines and SEO. I think this happens because sellers are so deeply immersed in their business that they are used to describing their products in a certain way.

‍Therefore, when buyers search, they type in a more general phrase, not an exact one. For example, a noun followed by adjectives that describe that noun or product. For instance: “wedding dress boho lace” instead of “lace boho wedding dress.” But often, as sellers, we’re more inclined to type “lace wedding dress boho” to describe the product rather than “boho lace wedding dress.”

‍Another example is a buyer searching for children’s bedding. Yes, they might type “nursery bedding minimalist neutral,” while a seller might use the words “neutral minimalist nursery bedding.” The point is, the word order should match what buyers are searching for. They type while they think, not think while they type. Remember this tip: it will have a huge impact on how you appear in search results before your target customers.

‍I hope now you know how to correctly write product descriptions on Etsy.

‍Wishing you successful sales!

The worst thing for Etsy SEO is when a seller tries to beautifully describe their product instead of directly naming what the buyer is searching for. In search, the winner is not the most poetic title, but the most relevant to the intent.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main mistake in Etsy SEO?

The main mistake is when the seller only describes the product itself, rather than its purpose, benefits, and how exactly the buyer searches for it.

Buyers often look for solutions, style, a gift, decor, the recipient, or the usage scenario of the product rather than technical specifications.

Because the beginning of the headline is the most valuable part for SEO. That’s where you should place the strongest key phrase.

These are more precise multi-word search phrases that combine product, style, purpose, event, or customer type.

First, it is worth rewriting the headline to suit the buyer’s intent, then updating the keywords, and if necessary — preparing a new listing variation with a different search focus.

Want to improve Etsy SEO without chaotic edits?

Start with headlines and keywords: rewrite them to match the buyer’s logic, not just the internal product description. This is the fastest way to increase the relevance of your listings in Etsy search.

Get a consultation on optimizing your Etsy shop

Консультантка з міжнародної торгівлі та доставки для e-commerce, власниця магазину на Etsy. Організаторка, співведуча, кураторка курсів для продавців на Etsy, Ebay, Shopify від Академії продажів Western Bid, які пройшли 1000 + учасників. Керівник маркетингового відділу компанії Western Bid.

✓ For Etsy sellers who want to improve listing visibility in search.

✓ For handmade, art, printable, and print-on-demand stores.

✓ For those who want to learn how to select keywords based on the buyer's intent, rather than the product's internal description.

✓ практичні рекомендації по запуску доставки

Learn about the 5 main barriers — based on 25 years of Western Bid’s experience in working with international e-commerce.



    A link to the video recording will be sent to your email.